Archive | November, 2011

Smart Phone or Feature Phone?

21 Nov

I have been on a journey since I decided to replace the home phone with a cell phone.  I was given a small feature phone months ago to use.  It is a nothing special flip phone type that works well.  The phone is not what I would call my ideal cell phone due to the tiny screen size on the front and slightly larger tiny screen inside.  The fact the phone is a flip phone makes it immune to accidental dialing phone numbers while in my pocket.  I wanted more, a lot more than a flip phone.

I called on my data provider from my tablet first to see what they have to offer.  Every phone I liked turned out to be a smart phone.  My provider starts data at $30 a month for 2 gigabytes; that is easy for me to stay under.  Except I already have a data plan and a smart phone requires another data plan.  Buying a phone could cost a few hundred dollars to free if I picked a not-so-good phone.  The voice plan for unlimited is $79.99, so I rounded things up to figure what I would pay monthly.  $80 for voice, $30(30) (data for tablet and phone) equals $140.  Way too much money for me to put out on a phone of any sort.  I’m not about to go around with my seven-inch tablet making Skype calls to everyone either.  My provider hit me $70 for voice, $10 for 1000 messages, $30 for data on the phone, and $30 for data on my tablet.  My provider also wanted me to pay $125 deposit because I haven’t had a phone with them before.  It was very difficult to keep this sentence free of obscenities.

It didn’t matter if I signed a two-year contract and paid money unless I paid the full price for the phone. Paying three or four hundred dollars for a phone is not something I will ever do.  I grew up with the rotary phone and the party line type of phone service.  The prices charged today for cell phones seem to come from someone’s delusional dreams.  I found myself included in the nightmare through no real fault of my own.  I first shunned twisted pair phone service when it started costing $45 to $50 dollars a month.  Costs kept going up and there was no changes made that I could see or read about.  I switched to voice over IP to reduce cost and thumb my nose at the terrestrial phone services.  My internet provider wooed me to their voip service and I readily took their bundled service.  When the bundle time limit came, the bill for voip went to the same as the local phone providers. I ditched them for a different voip that is much cheaper.  My only problem with voice over ip is when electricity is gone, so is your phone.  If there is an internet outage your phone service is out too.  That is why I got the bright idea of going totally cellular.

I found most the cell phones I liked are smartphones and too costly.  I did find a few feature phones I could tolerate.  I would still get slammed with $70 for unlimited voice and $10 a month for 1000 messages.  Those prices are unacceptable to me and I had to pay the $125 deposit still.  Then I discovered prepaid phones and $50 unlimited plans.  I found the honest truth my provider had been trying to tell me the whole time when I saw the prepaid offerings.  The truth as I see it; they will sell me crap starting at $50 a month for service and I have to pay for a very inferior phone.  The rest of the truth is selling off feature phones and stocks very few messaging phones that are not smart phones.  The only conclusion I could draw is my provider only wants to sell smart phones.  Smart phones aren’t so bad such as they are.

Really though, what need does the average person have for a smart phone?  Feature phones used to do all the things smart phones do except office applications.  Smart phones manage to do more than feature phones because they have an operating system that applications are written for.  Feature phones also have operating systems, but few applications are written for and made available for them.  My feature phone isn’t something I would call the ultimate phone.  I can surf the web some and do a number of other things similar to a smart phone. I can take a picture and manipulate it a few different ways.  Most of the other things on my feature phone are gimmicks designed to get me to pay them more.  I do have Bluetooth and some web browsing along with messaging.  I can use IM or text messaging all types because of the plan package I have.  The reason I don’t want a smart phone is I have a tablet that does all the smart phone things and I can see the screen.

The biggest disclosure I have is my Galaxy Tab I purchased through Verizon for less than $100 and a two-year contract.  That means I had to get a data plan through Verizon and their lowest plan starts at $30.  I pay them that fee for two gigabytes usage per month.  It is easy to use that much a month, but I have a WiFi router at home and I don’t travel much and use the 3G connection much.  I’ve already related what Verizon wanted for a phone with a contract plus a deposit.  The phones Verizon had to offer in their prepaid offerings are pathetic.  Sprint isn’t a company I’ll consider and neither is T-mobile.  Since I rejected Sprint I also rejected nearly all the contract cell phone services in my area.  I couldn’t find a phone I liked with them anyway.

I decided to take a look at AT&T.  I didn’t have much success other than finding more cell phones I liked.  I still ended up with a contract phone that would cost $80 to $90 a month plus a deposit over $100 dollars.  I browsed the web site and clicked on the magic words of prepaid.  I found a much wider selection of phones and even cheaper data fees.  For now AT&T will sell you 200 megabytes of data for $15 dollars.  To put that charge into perspective look at Verizon’s minimum $30 charge for 2 gigabytes of data.  By Verizon standards 1 gigabyte would cost $15 which means AT&T is grossly over charging for one fifth of a gigabyte.  AT&T charges $25 for 2 gigabytes of data.  Using AT&T rate for 2000 megabytes of data for $25.00 we end up at $.0125 per megabyte.  Calculating $15 for 200 megabytes of data is $.075 per megabyte.  Going further 4 gigabytes of data will cost $45.  The per megabyte charge there is $.01125.  That is a nice price break, or is it?  If multiplied by 2000 megabytes it comes to $22.50, but it would be a few dollars at 200 megabytes.  All of this math won’t help my price points though.

The first prepaid phone I picked out on AT&T turned out to be a smart phone.  I picked out a prepaid calling plan of $50 dollars giving me unlimited talk, text, and data (non-smart phone data) all nation wide.  All I had to do was pick a phone I could live with.  I wanted a step up from the flip phone I have and I chose a touch phone.  Looking back I may have done just as well with a slider phone.  I didn’t want buttons on the surface of the phone for accidental dialing.  All screens lock, so it doesn’t really matter.  I ended up with a phone that is OK for texting with a virtual keyboard.  The real kicker is the price point.  I paid $100 for the phone which is a one time charge.

What I learned is the phones on contract are newer versions usually costing $200 and up.  The calling plans are more expensive, but you can’t get all the items on prepaid.  I prefer the prepaid deal because I can buy another phone if I want without worry of a contract problem.  People that do use contract phones can get the latest phone provided they are at a point where their contract allows it.  I view buying a phone at low-cost on a contract the same as serving two years jail time.  I bought my tablet on contract because I know it will take a few years for the tablet market to actually evolve for me to want a new tablet.  My opinion on some cell phone prices is Occupy Wall Street should be holding rallies on iPhone and other smart phone prices.

What I found out today took me by surprise when  I got a human at AT&T.  The data pricing for the prepaid is different.  $5 for 10 megabytes, $15 for 100 megabytes, and $25 for 500 megabytes.  Ouch!  I found I could also buy data for my current phone to unlock some things like email and all that jazz.  My eyes give me fits over using my seven-inch tablet for email, I’m not going to try my phone.  The five dollar price tag on the very low ten megabytes of data would get me into a phone I would like.  I have to wonder who is kidding whom there though.  Perhaps after the first of the year I’ll sink more money into a new phone.  Adding a five dollar fee means spending $60 a year for nothing.  I did confirm the unlimited plan I have is wasting money for me as well.  The $2 a day plan would cost me $62 dollars max a month if I used my phone every day in a thirty-one day month.  If I use my phone twenty-five days a month I would spend $50 a month which is my unlimited full month cost.  I sometimes use my phone once a week and sometimes a few days a week.  I’m wasting my money; perhaps instead of figuring ways to waste more money, I should save.

Speed Testing on Cable Internet

3 Nov

I have a lot of things to say normally, but this subject should be short and sweet. All the internet speed tests we find out there are lies. All of them, no good; complete farces. It isn’t the deliberate design of the various testing sites; they are all fairly honest. The length of the test is what makes them inaccurate. A speed test will tell you the maximum speed of your connection at any given moment. What you don’t find out is what the actual connection speed is.

I have spent a lot of time recording my connection speed from three different testing sites. One site I have used for years and the other two sites for less than a year. I faithfully recorded my results even making a workbook in Microsoft Excel. Across three sites my internet connection speeds went from 22mbps to 16mbps download. Across those same three sites upload speeds were 2mbps to 4mbps. Those are nice speeds and in line with what my provider says I should get.

Actually my internet provider says I should expect speeds up to the lowest download speed, but does not guaranty any speed. I don’t know exactly how that works, but that is what they tell me. I should be happy I have those nice big numbers because they are so impressive. I did get the word on what my actual speed tier is because it was on the description way back when I signed up. Now it is described as up to 15mbps. I have 12/2 speed tier, I’ve had it for years. My core speed has only changed when there has been a problem with my connection. I have a tool that is available to the public called ShaperProbe. Every time I use it; my results show I have the 12/2 connection I’ve always had. I made the name of the tool a link to the tool for those who like to tinker with things.

Here is an example of how my results show I have my same old connection I’ve always had:

DiffProbe beta release. October 2009. Build 1002.

Shaper Detection Module.

Connected to server 80.239.168.215.

Estimating capacity:

Upstream: 4190 Kbps.

Downstream: 20066 Kbps.

The measurement will take up to 2.5 minutes. Please wait.

Checking for traffic shapers:

Upstream: Burst size: 4677-4752 KB;

Shaping rate: 2128 Kbps.

Downstream: Burst size: 9681-10031 KB;

Shaping rate: 12768 Kbps.

For more information, visit: http://www.cc.gatech.edu/~partha/diffprobe

Below is my maximum connection speed.

Estimating capacity:

Upstream: 4190 Kbps.

Downstream: 20066 Kbps

Below is the upload with the shaped rate is my rate

Upstream: Burst size: 4677-4752 KB;

Shaping rate: 2128 Kbps.

Below is my download with the shaped rate is my rate

Downstream: Burst size: 9681-10031 KB;

Shaping rate: 12768 Kbps.

My connection speed is 12mbps/2mbps Tada!

I did go out of my way to record speed tests from three different sites for a long time knowing they only measured maximum speed at that moment.  Maximum speed is good to know, it wasn’t valuable to me because my real speed was not found.  Even ShaperProbe does not allow for a completely relative condition like internet weather.  ShaperProbe will tell you how much of a boost your ISP gives you right off.  There are so many different factors that come into play when connections are made on the internet.  From slow servers to congestion of internet traffic, there are too many factors to count.

The last thing I want to say is that the speed test sites are not lying if you want to see your maximum speed at the moment.  The speed test sites are no good for much else unless there are forums, news, and the like also.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.